Please
go see "Pope Francis: A Man of His Word," the 2018 documentary by Wim
Wenders. Just by going to a theater to see this film, you will be making the
world a better place. Why? Because this is a beautiful, moving, engaging film
about life's big questions. It turns its camera on people so poor they live in
garbage dumps, on pollution, mass migration, on victims of natural disasters, and
asks how to respond to all this in an ethical way.
About
how many other movies can you say that? If you financially reward the makers of
this film, more filmmakers will produce more beautiful, deep movies. And the
world will be a better place.
Almost
from the first moments of this film to the last, I had tears running down my
face. I'm a movie lover and I loved this movie, not just because it is good in
a moral sense, but because it is well made. Wim Wenders, the filmmaker as well
as the narrator, is an award-winning director who gave us "Wings of
Desire" and "The Buena Vista Social Club."
The
film opens, in a sense, in heaven. Wenders turns his camera on heavenly clouds.
Wenders' voiceover lists all that is wrong with the world, and asks how we can
go on. The clouds break, and Wenders shows us an ancient Italian town, and
invokes another Francis, St. Francis of Assisi. Wenders uses mention of the
medieval St. Francis to highlight the life of the current Pope Francis.
Francis
is shown carrying out his day-to-day life. He visits with very poor people in
places like Brazil, the Philippines, and the Central African Republic. He has
intimate contact with the sick, those disposed by hurricanes, and the aged.
Those he visits tremble during their encounters. Their eyes glow. They weep. They
exult.
Francis
also visits the wealthy and powerful: Vladimir Putin, the Trumps, and congress.
American legislators John Boehner, Marco Rubio, and others are shown helplessly
wiping away tears as Francis speaks.
In
other scenes, Francis looks directly into Wenders' camera and speaks from his
heart. He teaches with confidence and authority, but in a kindly, not a
didactic or superior, way.
You don't
have to agree with everything Francis says to cherish this movie. I certainly don’t.
On the one hand, as I watched, my rational mind developed arguments against
some of Francis' positions. But my heart was still moved, because Francis is so
obviously a well-meaning person trying to make his way through a very
challenging world.
I
disagree with Francis most on two related points. First, he says that one
should never assume an attitude of proselytizing. I disagree. Christians must
proselytize. Maybe there is a nuance here I am missing. If so, the film never
clarifies.
Francis
appears to endorse the mass migration of unvetted, military-age Muslims into
Europe while, in the film, in any case, ignoring the real-world problems caused
by that migration. And Francis romanticizes poverty, in my opinion.
Rather
than romanticizing poverty, Francis should endorse efforts to end poverty. If
women's status were elevated, and if women controlled their own fertility,
their societies would advance and there would be fewer people living in abject
poverty. Further, capitalism and even greed should not be demonized. Jesus had
warm relations with rich people, and he spoke of the necessity to build on
investments.
Francis
says kind things about women and homosexuals without advancing any change in
policy that would communicate the official church recognition of the full
humanity of women and homosexuals, not just heterosexual men.
Even
when I was disagreeing with Francis, I was loving this movie.
Now,
to the naysayers. In "The Federalist," Maureen Mullarkey called the
film "religious pornography" and identified Pope Francis as analogous
to Hitler. Movie reviews don't get any weirder than that. Mullarkey hates
Francis' kind words about homosexuals. She trashes the film.
This
hateful review is followed by comments by hundreds of hateful people, some
identifying as Catholic, who are utterly comfortable comparing Pope Francis to
Hitler.
For
that reason alone, you need to see this movie.
No comments:
Post a Comment