"Star
Trek Beyond" is standard-issue Star Trek. There are lots of costumes that
aren't all that convincing. There is lots of danger that an evil genius might destroy
the universe. There is lots of chasing and gizmo-tinkering that saves the
universe at the last minute. It's all completely implausible and runs on
arbitrary rules, but that's nothing new for sci/fi or fantasy movies.
The
special effects of outer space and human habitation of it are higher quality
than in the old TV show, of course. Starbase Yorktown is a series of rods
radiating out from the center of a transparent sphere. Humans inhabit these
rods, all of which appear to have their own gravity. There is no garbage in the
streets and everyone is young, beautiful, and healthy, which is kind of creepy
if you think about it too long.
The main
characters perform their old tricks: Kirk is recklessly heroic, Spock is
logical, Bones is crabby, Scottie messes with dilithium crystals, Sulu pilots
the ship and is shown reuniting with his newly-minted male partner and
daughter, and Chekov gets to joke about how a Russian invented something, a
Cold-War-era joke that younger people won't understand at all, but that will
give Baby Boomer Trekkies a chuckle. Of all the traditional cast members, Chekov
is given the least to do. This is rather sad since Anton Yelchin, the actor who
plays Chekov, died in a freak accident in June, 2016. There is also Jaylah, a
space girl who looks a bit like Darth Maul. In TOS, Kirk was the most heroic.
Not so here; everyone shines equally. Every participant wins a trophy. This
insistence on making every character as heroic as Kirk lessens the differences
between the characters and makes the interplay between the ensemble less fun.
The
plot involves an evil genius who wants to destroy the universe, and the
Enterprise crew stopping him.
Star
Trek plots are always examined for possible societal significance. This plot
may be a reference to The West v. Terrorism. In the beginning of "Star Trek
Beyond" Kirk narrates a world-weary monologue. Life is too placid, too
predictable. He needs a new challenge. This may be the scriptwriters, including
Simon Pegg, who plays Scottie, voicing the post-WWII-era West becoming too
comfortable. The villain of the piece, Krall, wants to re-introduce pointless
violence and hate into an all-too-comfortable universe. Or maybe not. This is
Star Trek; feel free to come up with your own interpretation.
The
one character change in this reboot that saddens me most is Uhura. I loved Nichelle
Nichols' Uhura. I loved her because she was an accurate depiction of a woman in
a man's world. I also loved it that she was black. My family were immigrants
and her minority status was an inspiration to me. She was a communications
officer, the kind of job a woman would typically have. She was in the
background, as women often are in men's stories. She was someone I could embrace,
relate to, and be inspired by.
In
the reboot, Uhura is not really African American. Zoe Saldana is a light-skinned
Hispanic. Uhura's difference has been toned down. And Uhura has become a
leader, an action hero, as karate-happy as Captain Kirk. Conversely, she spends
a good amount of her time playing a stereotypical role assigned to ethnic
women. She is the hot, exotic temptress who will lure cold Spock into a love
relationship. The original Uhura's sexiness was never exploited in this way.
No comments:
Post a Comment