Zanoli Family Source: NYT |
Hank Zanoli Source: Haaretz |
Henk Zanoli is a 91 year old Dutchman and recipient of
the Righteous Gentile award from Yad Vashem. During the recent violence in
Gaza, several people to whom Zanoli is distantly related by marriage were
killed. Mr. Zanoli decided to return his medal to the Israeli embassy. He sent
a letter to the embassy accusing Israel of being the sole cause of problems in
the Middle East. He specifically said that Israel is a racist country. He
demanded that Israel become, in effect, a borderless, pacifist state, and that
it cease defending itself. Only then, he stipulated, would Israel be worthy of
the word "righteous," and able to respond appropriately to his own
heroism.
Dear Henk Zanoli,
Henk Zanoli when I heard that you, a 91-year-old
righteous Gentile, had returned your Yad Vashem medal because you object to
Israel defending itself against Hamas, I felt revulsion. My very first thought
was, "Oh my God, it's true. They really do like their Jews passive, in gas
chambers, and dead, not active, not able to defend themselves against the
genocidal forces arrayed against them."
And I thought, too, that at 91 your faculties might not
be sharp enough to realize what a propaganda coup you were handing the genocidal
antisemites.
I read more about you on the web.
I rapidly saw from your letter to the Israeli embassy
that your mind is sharp as a tack.
I read of your heroic sacrifice, and the sacrifices of
your family.
You performed awesome feats of bravery, Mr. Zanoli. You
smuggled an eleven-year-old Jewish child from Amsterdam into your village and
you sheltered that child throughout the war, saving his life. He eventually
moved to Israel. You did this in spite of your family being under suspicion.
Your father, may God grant him eternal reward, was an active resister of the
Nazis. Your father was sent to Dachau concentration camp, and he died at the Mauthausen
concentration camp. The rest of your family struggled and sacrificed as well.
Your brother-in-law was executed for being part of the resistance. Your brother's
Jewish fiancée was deported to certain death.
You are great people, Mr. Zanoli. I respect you.
I am very sorry for the loss of life your family
sustained in the recent conflict between Israel and Hamas.
I read the letter that accompanied the medal you sent
back to the Israelis.
You wrote, "the Zionist project had from its
beginning a racist element aspiring to build a state exclusively for Jews"
and "Your state continues to suppress the Palestinian people" Israel,
you say, must treat everyone equally. Once Israel does that, you say, it will
be a "righteous" state, and able to reward you for your own
righteousness.
Sir, with respect, I have to tell you that what you wrote
in that letter is not true.
Israel is not the root cause of your relatives' deaths.
It is the refusal of Muslim Arabs to accept the existence of Jews as sovereign in
their own homeland that caused your relatives' deaths.
If Israelis put down their weapons as you require in
order to call them "righteous," they would, within days, all be dead,
imprisoned or enslaved.
That would not be the first or the last time a Jewish
community was wiped out by Muslims. It would not be the first or the last time
a non-Muslim community was wiped out in the Middle East. You've heard of the
fate of Christians in Mosul, Iraq? In Syria? In Egypt? You are familiar with
the fate of the Yazidi?
Christianity goes back in the Middle East for two
thousand years. Judaism goes back in the Middle East four thousand years. The
Zoroastrian roots of Yazidi go back even further than that. Islam is a relative
newcomer. If you want to support the indigenous group, you would be supporting
the Yazidis, Jews, and Christians.
The Muslim Conquest of the Middle east began 1400 years
ago, and it is still going strong, and its proponents don't want it to stop
till the map is covered by the black flag of jihad, with no interruptions in
color.
Hamas, in its charter, calls for the deaths of all Jews.
In its long-term goals, it includes the re-establishment of a caliphate and
worldwide Muslim domination. Please read the Hamas Charter. Please listen to
Mosab Hassan Yousef, son of a Hamas founder.
Please acquaint yourself with how Muslim-majority states
have treated Jews, who came to be as a people in the land of Israel thousands
of years before Arabs left their peninsula for their world conquest. Read Bat
Yeor, Andrew Bostom, Robert Spencer, Bernard Lewis.
Mr. Zanoli, did you know that long before the Nazis
required Jews to wear a yellow star, Muslim states required Jews and Christians
to wear clothing patches in the shapes of monkeys and pigs? Did you know that
as recently as 1834, Sol Hachuel, a Jewish woman in Morrocco was decapitated
for refusing to become a Muslim? Did you know that in "Golden Age"
Muslim Spain Muslims crucified a Jew, Joseph ibn Naghrela, and massacred
thousands of Jews in one day? Did you know that perhaps a million Jews had to
leave Muslim countries in 1948? Egypt, Yemen, Tunisia, Algeria, Libya – Do you
know they were chased by rioting, murder, theft, rape?
Hamas is not unique and it is not new. Islam has had a
huge problem with the mere existence of
Jews since Islam's founding. No matter where those Jews were. Remember, this is
a belief system that insists that the day will come when even rocks and trees
will shout out, "Oh, Muslim, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come kill
him."
When you ignore this, Mr. Zanoli, no matter how heroic your
deeds were in World War II, no matter how sad your current bereavement, what
you say is garbage. It is worse than not worth listening to. It is an aural
toxin that gives a victory to antisemites who are every bit as deadly and as
much of a threat to world peace as were the Nazis whom your father fought so
bravely.
Whether you can face it or not, Mr. Zanoli, propaganda
coups like yours empower bastards like Hamas, and ensure the death of more
innocents like your kin who died.
If all of you "Jews are racist baby killers; Hamas
are noble freedom fighters" types would shut up, Hamas just might get it
that their propaganda war is not working, and they might, they just might, try
coexistence.
You fuel the flames of war. Hard to face, I know.
Please educate yourself, Mr. Zanoli, before you speak
again in such a public way.
It wasn't Jews who killed your kin. It was Jew-hatred.
You used to fight that, remember?
It's not too late to rejoin the good guys, the folks
working for peace for all.
We'll keep a seat at the table for you.
Wonderful. And so sad that this is needed.
ReplyDeleteThank you! Finally seven years later this blog post receives a comment! :-)
Delete